How Many Daycare Van Deaths Does It Take???

Collapse
X
 
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • Cat Herder
    Advanced Daycare.com Member
    • Dec 2010
    • 13744

    How Many Daycare Van Deaths Does It Take???

    Law to prevent child daycare van deaths fails to pass
    by Katie Lagrone 5/23/11

    PALM BEACH COUNTY, Fla. - Nearly one year after 2 1/2 year old Haile Brockington's young body was left behind strapped in a hot daycare van, a bill designed to save other children from the same tragic ending failed to become law.

    "It's sad, very sad," said Democrat State Senator Maria Sachs of Delray Beach. Sachs proposed "Haile's Bill," which would require all Florida daycare vans be equipped with alarms that must be manually turned off. The alarms would require drivers to walk to the back of the vans to turn them off making sure no child is left behind.

    The bill passed unanimously in the Senate, but failed in the House of Representatives. Sachs says politics got in the way.

    "The Speaker of the House said they were not going to hear any of my bills. I was like ‘please let this one pass, this one's important’ and he said no," said Sachs.

    Haile's bill was the senator's first priority bill.

    What the bill would have done has already been a priority to Katie Muhammad, owner of Katie's Kids, where Haile died. Four months after the little girl’s death, Muhammad spent $6,000 equipping all of her transportation vehicles with similar child alarm systems.

    "I'm very disappointed in legislation for not passing that because that's a huge problem we have and will continue to have," said Muhammad. "There's always going to be human error, there's been recent incidents where children have still been left in vehicles," she said.

    It was an effort born out of tragedy that is now being put on hold indefinitely.

    "To think that Florida being such a dangerously hot time in the summer, that we would have to go through another summer without this technology really shows that politics gets in the way of safety," said Sachs.

    Haile Brockington's mother said the fact that the bill did not pass was a real shame. “This says, the issue is more important to parents, than lawmakers, " said Nelder Lester.

    Sachs will introduce the bill next session. In the meantime, she plans on contacting every daycare center in Florida over the next few weeks, encouraging them to invest in alarm systems without the legislative mandate.

    2 Arrested in Toddler Daycare Van Death Out on Bond
    By: Ruth Manuel-Logan 06/22/2011

    The two Georgia adults who stand accused of leaving a toddler to roast to death in a daycare van were released on bond early Tuesday evening.

    Two-year-old Jazmin Green (pictured) passed away Monday afternoon, after she was left to sit in a van for two hours outside Marlo's Magnificent Early Learning Center after returning from a field trip.

    Marlo Maria Fallings, 41, and her daughter, Quantabia Shantell Hopkins, 23, were arrested in the wee hours of Tuesday morning and charged with cruelty to children, involuntary manslaughter and reckless conduct. A third unnamed underage teen was also taken in to custody.

    As temperatures reached the mid-90's on Monday afternoon, the daycare staff and children had just returned from a visit to a Chuck E. Cheese restaurant at about 2 p.m. An hour and a half later, Hopkins noticed that Jazmin was missing. When the daycare provider went to the parking lot to search for the child, she found her in the van (pictured below), still strapped in her carseat.

    Authorities were called on to the scene and the toddler was rushed to the Southern Regional Medical Center in nearby Riverdale. Despite doctor's efforts, Jazmin Green was pronounced dead

    Child Care Worker Arrested in Brevard County Florida for Leaving 19 Month Old in "Hot" Van - Dangers of 102 Degree Heat to Children
    August 18 by David A. Wolf

    In Cocoa (Brevard County), Florida, a day care worker (Rondalyn Dixon) was arrested for leaving a 19 month child unattended in a hot day care van. It was reported that the child was left in the vehicle for about 15 minutes. When deputies from the Brevard County Sheriff's Office arrived, the temperature was 102 degrees

    I could go on and on (I am sure you guys can google....but you get the point. Why wont states do something???
    - Unless otherwise stated, all my posts are personal opinion and worth what you paid for them.
  • WImom
    Advanced Daycare.com Member
    • Jun 2010
    • 1639

    #2
    So sad. We have to have the van alarms here in WI even for inhome daycare for my minivan.

    Comment

    • sharlan
      Daycare.com Member
      • May 2011
      • 6067

      #3
      I don't know anything about these alarms, so I can't say anything pro or con.

      BUT, I have driven a Suburban or van for 27 years. You have to take the time to count heads and check the vehicle. There is NO excuse for a child being left in a vehicle. It is the responsibility of the person in charge (ME) to see to it that all children are properly buckled into carseats or seatbelted. I don't put the car into gear before I check.

      When we get somewhere, I do a headcount to make sure all are accounted for BEFORE going into the store, to the playground, etc. Again, when leaving, I do another headcount and check belts. When we get back home, I am the last one to leave the vehicle, check for forgotten items and sippy cups. Once I get into the house, I do another headcount. It's always possible that one disappeared before making it the 20 ft to the front door while I double check the van.

      Once again, it is MY responsibility to see to the children's safety, not my assistant's.

      A couple of years ago, we had a young preschooler that was picked up by school bus at the school, but the driver FORGOT to drop him off at home. By the time the parents got ahold of somebody from the school district, Friday evening, the child had died. As I recall, the bus driver was allowed to retire.

      Comment

      • sharlan
        Daycare.com Member
        • May 2011
        • 6067

        #4
        Please explain the alarms to me.

        Comment

        • Auntie
          Daycare.com Member
          • Jun 2011
          • 181

          #5
          We do not travel with kids at our center. However, even before entering from outside we line up count and do a face to name off our sign in sheet.

          Comment

          • Meyou
            Advanced Daycare.com Member
            • Feb 2011
            • 2734

            #6
            I just don't understand how you can not know a child is missing for 2 hours when they're in your care.

            Comment

            • Kaddidle Care
              Daycare.com Member
              • Dec 2010
              • 2090

              #7
              It's just plain common sense not to leave a child in the car and Childcare providers know to do head counts before and after entering a vehicle.

              Yet there are still people that are careless, lazy, etc. and will leave a child in a car because they are going in the store for "just a minute". (You KNOW that doesn't happen - ever.)

              It's also sad when people have so many children that they loose track of them! My husband worked at a Sears store years ago and a large family came in for Portraits. They all went home and they left behind a 3-4 year old. When they called the family they actually argued with the Store Manager that they didn't leave him behind. THEN they did a head count. Oopsie! Thank goodness the child was safe and surprisingly calm. Perhaps this had happened to him before.

              I honestly don't think car alarms are a good thing as people will rely on them and what if THEY fail? Good old fashioned head counting and keeping track of children is all that is needed to keep them safe.

              Now don't get me started on people that leave pets in the car.

              Comment

              • countrymom
                Daycare.com Member
                • Aug 2010
                • 4874

                #8
                I don't understand how you can forget a child. When I travel with the kids (I have a passanger van so I can acually walk to the back) I unbuckle everyone first before I open the door. I even do a head count of my own children.

                Last year a disabled boy was left on the bus for over 2 hours infront of the school. And luckily the dad dressed him in snow pants that day because he wanted to play outside, thats why he survived. And you know what the dad said, he knows that nothing will be done about what happened because no one cares in ontario and guess what, he was right. The driver was fired thats it. My dcm worked at the school.

                Comment

                • Blackcat31
                  • Oct 2010
                  • 36124

                  #9
                  :confused::confused:

                  How does a person who cares for multiple children at one time NOT do a silent headcount a bajillion times a day?????? I know I do. This type of thing is going to prevent any child care provider from ever being able to use a vehicle for children in care. Field trips will start being mandated to on-foot only...... Every single person in these cases should be held accountable for their actions 100%. NO EXCUSES.

                  Comment

                  • SimpleMom
                    Senior Member
                    • Jun 2009
                    • 586

                    #10
                    tears

                    oh my gosh, I'm in tears over this I can't imagine going through that as a parent or provider. I can't imagine going through that as the child unable to get out of a hot vehicle. How frightening.
                    Thank you for the post. Bet if enough people got together and petitioned they'd hear it and pass it.

                    Comment

                    • Cat Herder
                      Advanced Daycare.com Member
                      • Dec 2010
                      • 13744

                      #11
                      The daycare falsified records in the Georgia case above...

                      I don't understand when the first thought after the death of a child is to cover your own ass.

                      - Unless otherwise stated, all my posts are personal opinion and worth what you paid for them.

                      Comment

                      • Blackcat31
                        • Oct 2010
                        • 36124

                        #12
                        Originally posted by Catherder
                        The daycare falsified records in the Georgia case above...

                        I don't understand when the first thought after the death of a child is to cover your own ass.

                        http://www.ajc.com/news/clayton/day-...in-986181.html
                        Another example of a self-centered society. :confused:

                        Comment

                        • Cat Herder
                          Advanced Daycare.com Member
                          • Dec 2010
                          • 13744

                          #13
                          Originally posted by Blackcat31
                          Another example of a self-centered society. :confused:
                          I am giving her a shadow of a doubt in the fact that the other provider arrested was her daughter... That somehow she felt that the innocent baby was already gone and tried to save her own... :confused:

                          Even then, what future would she have set her up for..

                          I know the alarms are not the answer, but maybe if they were legislated then fewer people would get off with just a slap on the hand and probation when it happens again because the excuses are no longer relevant. YKWIM?

                          When the price for this is much higher, maybe it will stay sharper in providers minds....:confused: IDK, I just hate this keeps happening every summer.
                          - Unless otherwise stated, all my posts are personal opinion and worth what you paid for them.

                          Comment

                          • kidkair
                            Celebrating Daily!
                            • Aug 2010
                            • 673

                            #14
                            I don't know if alarms would help or be able to be enforced well enough but maybe a law with a steep sentence for any one who leaves a child in an unattended vehicle or leaves a child behind at a store or park would do better. I mean getting fired is not that big of a deal or getting your child back as if you forgot your cell phone. If instead they had jail time hanging over their heads maybe more would do a better head count.
                            I do a head count very often and I only have to get to 4 right now. I panicked once after nap because I counted heads and was one short when we got outside. I calmed down when I realized one had headed home early and my brain just didn't catch it for the head counting.
                            Celebrate! ::

                            Comment

                            • Blackcat31
                              • Oct 2010
                              • 36124

                              #15
                              Originally posted by Catherder
                              I am giving her a shadow of a doubt in the fact that the other provider arrested was her daughter... That somehow she felt that the innocent baby was already gone and tried to save her own... :confused:Even then, what future would she have set her up for..

                              I know the alarms are not the answer, but maybe if they were legislated then fewer people would get off with just a slap on the hand and probation when it happens again because the excuses are no longer relevant. YKWIM?

                              When the price for this is much higher, maybe it will stay sharper in providers minds....:confused: IDK, I just hate this keeps happening every summer.
                              ....reminds me of the Caylee Anthony trial where Casey's mother just testified yesterday that she was the one who was searching for chloroform and visiting MySpace on the internet not her daughter. I get that she is trying to save her daughter (considering that her granddaughter is already lost) but really!?!?!?

                              Comment

                              Working...